FA Cup 3rd round

[Schards#2]

Both feet left the ground; therefore I'm not sure you can argue against me suggesting he jumped into the challenge....


Whether he one it or won it with just one foot is irrelevant, IMHO.

Both feet are off the ground at some stage during the act of running, so that would be 20 reds within the first five minutes of every game then? He won the ball fairly with one foot and the tackled player, Nani, didn't even appeal fr a foul, as it clearly wasn't one.

[who are ya?]

How comes the southerners have out sung the gr8est fans in Manchester from the start

[Schards#2]

How comes the southerners have out sung the gr8est fans in Manchester from the start

Because they are the away team, that's what away teams do.

The song should be "you're supposed to be away"

[Tails]

Both feet left the ground; therefore I'm not sure you can argue against me suggesting he jumped into the challenge....


Whether he one it or won it with just one foot is irrelevant, IMHO.

Both feet are off the ground at some stage during the act of running, so that would be 20 reds within the first five minutes of every game then? He won the ball fairly with one foot and the tackled player, Nani, didn't even appeal fr a foul, as it clearly wasn't one.

Don't be so obtuse. Its not very becoming of you.

[Schards#2]

Both feet left the ground; therefore I'm not sure you can argue against me suggesting he jumped into the challenge....


Whether he one it or won it with just one foot is irrelevant, IMHO.

Both feet are off the ground at some stage during the act of running, so that would be 20 reds within the first five minutes of every game then? He won the ball fairly with one foot and the tackled player, Nani, didn't even appeal fr a foul, as it clearly wasn't one.

Don't be so obtuse. Its not very becoming of you.

You'd be better just to admit you called it wrong at first look TBH, there's no shame in and that's what the ref will do tomorrow.

[soggy biscuit]

Lol @ all the UTD badge kissing going on

[who are ya?]

Oops

[Tails]

Please, Shards....you are not coming across very well here.



Welbeck with a very nice finish. 2-0.

[Handsome Man]

I just checked: both feet were off the ground at the same time.

It's a red card - you lose control when that happens.

[Schards#2]

Please, Shards....you are not coming across very well here.



Welbeck with a very nice finish. 2-0.

Sorry if pointing out that a ref had made a howler offends you in some way

[rhroyal]

Everybody knows 2 feet means red these days. Winning the ball doesn't matter. We've seen plenty of "harsh" reds this season, but it appears refs are being consistent with this one. Kompany can't complain.

The logic is that without a foot remaining on the ground, you don't have much control at all and could very easily break a leg even if there is no malicious intent. Right decision in today's context; players need to learn to stop diving in on 2 feet instead of complaining about the reds they receive.

[who are ya?]

How comes the southerners have out sung the gr8est fans in Manchester from the start

Because they are the away team, that's what away teams do.

The song should be "you're supposed to be away"

But aren't they all tourists who don't cre8 an atmosphere

[Tails]

Please, Shards....you are not coming across very well here.



Welbeck with a very nice finish. 2-0.

Sorry if pointing out that a ref had made a howler offends you in some way

Nope, your ability to carry out a convincing argument in a sensible way could be deemed offensive....

[Handsome Man]

Everybody knows 2 feet means red these days. Winning the ball doesn't matter. We've seen plenty of "harsh" reds this season, but it appears refs are being consistent with this one. Kompany can't complain.

The logic is that without a foot remaining on the ground, you don't have much control at all and could very easily break a leg even if there is no malicious intent. Right decision in today's context; players need to learn to stop diving in on 2 feet instead of complaining about the reds they receive.

Agreed. Why complain when refs are being consistent?

[Simon's Church]

Never a red. Great finish by Welbeck though.

[Schards#2]

Everybody knows 2 feet means red these days. Winning the ball doesn't matter. We've seen plenty of "harsh" reds this season, but it appears refs are being consistent with this one. Kompany can't complain.

The logic is that without a foot remaining on the ground, you don't have much control at all and could very easily break a leg even if there is no malicious intent. Right decision in today's context; players need to learn to stop diving in on 2 feet instead of complaining about the reds they receive.

But this isn't a two footed challange

[Tails]

LOL; penalty to United.

[sandman]

Only just started watching so haven't seen the red. How the hell is Chris Foy refereeing a Manchester Derby after Monday?

[Simon's Church]

Welbeck showing an imaginary card. Fvcking foreigners ruining our game!

[who are ya?]