Which keeper would you rather have?

[No Fixed Abode]

poor fishing m8. Must try harder.

[1871 Royal]

I asked the guys in my seminar tutor this question, they all said SG, even the Chelsea fan! His explanation was that based on this season and a few seasons before PC has been rather poor.

[No Fixed Abode]

poor fishing m8. Must try harder.

[SLAMMED]

Given his current form, I'd say Shay.

[1871 Royal]

Nice play on words there S.

[No Fixed Abode]

Given at fault for Stokes goal last night. Also conceded another perfectly good goal which was rule out.

[Starfish]

[No Fixed Abode]

Cech on Saturday

[sandman]

Casillas and Buffon are better than both. Remember a couple of seasons ago Casillas had the most shots against him in La Liga yet still won the award for the least goals conceded.

Both Keepers mentioned are pretty even. I think the lack of competiton for Cech since Cudicini left Chelsea has seen his standards drop. Whereas Given knows that if his performances drop off Hart could comeback from his loan next season and be number one.

[soggy biscuit]

Casillas and Buffon are better than both.

Amen sister. Though these days when it comes to goalkeeping in La LIga no one can touch Almeria's Diego Alves.

[sandman]

Good keeper. Both Madrid and Milan are looking at him apparently. He'd be wasted playing understudy to Casillas.