by Stranded »
31 Aug 2010 11:22
andrew1957 Stranded andrew1957 Well I for one am still fuming about this.
some of you seem to think £6M is a good fee but you are bonkers IMO. Siggy was the one truly PL class player that we have in the squad. The sort of player that will most likely go for £20M plus sooner or later. He is the sort of player that could just have fired us to the PL in what is an extremely tight division. He is then the sort of player that would have given us a slim chance of PL survival. Now we have no hope other than mid table mediocrity and if we replace him with a Championship class CB and a League 1 class player in Fryatt then we really are going down the tubes. I would rather we bought no one at all as we have no hope of promotion now in any case.
I have supported the club through thick and thin but this is utter madness.
Save your anger for if no-one comes in today. I'm not happy he's left but Siggy was always going to go at some point - we were unlikely to go up this year and we were never going to get more than £6m for him.
IF we use some of the money to make the squad more balanced then this will have been a good bit of business.
Surely you are missing the point. Yes we might bring in a few has-beens or Championship standard players - who might lead us to survival but this means the end of PL ambition. I honestly believe Sig would have scored 20 plus goals this season. I do not think we will find a replacement who can do that and the rest and of the squad Matt Mills is the most likely to be top scorer from what I have seen so far. If as fans we have no hope I really wonder what will motivate many of us to turn up week in week out.
I have naively believed that the cub did want to get back to the PL at some stage but this sale clearly means that I was completely wrong.
No, the point is his 20 goals would most likely not lead to promotion - like his 20 didn't last season. Players leave all the time and this was an inevitability as he is a talent that is far bigger than our club could ever wish to hold on to. Even if we were in the Prem, he would have been picked off at some point.
If we do not balance the squad by using this money then we are in trouble but if we do get what we need then the team might actually be better despite the sum of its parts being weaker. As has been said whilst Siggy's eye for goal cannot be doubted and was very important to us, more often than not he could be preipheral (sp?) to a game.
2 or 3 astute signings (or loans) on the back of this
could well help the team out and push on to a play-off place. We have a manager who knows what is out there probably better than many due to his previous role, so lets wait and see who runs out on the 11th Sept before we spontaneously combust over a sale that was inevitable.